A breakthrough solution to eradicate
the traffic problems
in and around Port Louis
This document outlines in a very broad sense a breakthrough
solution to eradicate the traffic problems in and around Port Louis. Due to
the complexity of the problem, technical details for design and implementation
have been left for the appropriate experts.
The proposal is not only more practical and easier to
implement, it is also cheaper and addresses more than just traffic problems.
The document firstly paints a quick picture of the current
situation and then explains how the proposed solution solves step by step
the different issues raised.
The layout of this report is as follows:
1. TRAFFIC CONGESTION: The Causes
1.1. Bottleneck at entrances and exits
The principal cause of traffic jam is due to the configuration
of Port Louis. It can be compared to a bottle with a small neck. The entrances,
and therefore by implication the exits, are so small that they do not permit
a rapid movement of traffic at peak hours, when the number of vehicles entering
the City is innumerable. However, it should be pointed out that it is very
common nowadays that even outside peak time, there is traffic congestion.
It is as if, it
has become forcefully a way of life. Should we surrender
to this problem?
1.2. Convergence of traffic from several directions
In addition to the bottleneck problem, there is a convergence
of traffic at the main entrance of Port Louis. Traffic from north to south
and vice versa have to inevitably converge with traffic entering and leaving
the City. This is where the traffic congestion accentuates further to the
point of paralysing the whole Capital area.
1.3. Narrow roads and ever-increasing number of vehicles
Other than its shape, Port Louis is becoming relatively
smaller over time, because of the
ever-increasing number of vehicles driving in and out. Moreover, most of the
main roads are narrow and the flow of traffic is severely hampered. As parking
takes half of the width of the roads, the situation is further aggravated.
To sum up, the main cause of the problem is thus, Port
Louis itself. As a result of its configuration, the Capital City can no longer
accommodate the ever-increasing traffic both driving in and through its territory.
There is no room for any enlargement of its entrances as building infrastructures
have taken too much space. Hence, the only solution is to control the flow
of traffic and in so doing we can with a certitude get rid of the traffic
congestion. However, we should not forget that the traffic congestion has
other associated problems as
well and we, therefore, have to tackle the overall situation.
This is what this report is about to do indeed.
Now let us consider the resulting problems in the following
section.
2. TRAFFIC CONGESTION: The Resulting Problems
2.1. Lateness at work
This is the most obvious consequence of traffic problems.
The workers are late on the workplace. This results to decrease in productivity
and efficiency and therefore a considerable loss in terms of man hours paid,
but with no output for the organisation and finally for the country.
2.2. Pressure of punctuality on the workers
However, many workers are very keen to be in time at
work and as such they have to bear the undue pressure of punctuality. Other
than traffic problems, poor bus services do make things worse for them. Many
workers are compelled to get on already crowded buses, as straphangers, in
a desperate attempt to be punctual. The route No. 198 is a flagrant example
of such everyday scene. How could they be efficient when they have to face
such pressures prior to start working?
2.3. Stress on the drivers
Likewise, the drivers are very stressed on the roads.
This is so due to the race against time that they have to embark into. There
is the need to catch up lost time in traffic jam and to be punctual. Are they
driving safely? Is it not one of the causes of accidents? And what is the
productivity at office after going through this entire ordeal?
2.4. Parking problems
The search for a convenient parking slot is another sort
of headache for the drivers after having made a long and tedious journey.
As a result of the limited parking space in Port Louis, they are sanctioned
by penalties.
2.5. Loss in foreign currency reserves
Every time a vehicle has to start again, after a stop
due to traffic congestion, entails to an increase in fuel consumption. It
follows that traffic jam leads to unnecessary drainage of foreign currency
reserves as fuel is imported. Figures that were published in the press turn
around Rs.500 millions per annum. Here, we should not put aside the additional
increase of toxic smoke emission in the atmosphere.
2.6. Air pollution
Obviously, the air in the city is subject to inevitable
pollution. These days we are talking of the greenhouse effect. Before we would
reach the critical situation of some overseas cities, we should take preventive
measures as it is still time. However, the air has already been affected when
we can notice the difference in the evening and especially during weekends
when the number of vehicles are very low in Port Louis. It is amazing and
also alarming to
note this big gap. Should the situation be left unattended,
there is no doubt that we would have to face unwanted problems ahead.
2.7. Noise pollution
Needless to say that we have noise pollution too in the
city, mainly caused by the traffic driving in and out. Port Louis is the seat
of power in Mauritius. It means that major decisions and works are done in
this place. As a matter of fact, it is sine qua non that a reasonable working
environment should prevail at all times.
2.8. Impact on the climatic conditions - Micro Climats
Along with the problems of air and noise pollution, our
meteorologists have found that there are micro climats in the Capital City.
Does this not confirm its slow degrading atmospheric state? Again, is it not
the greenhouse effect?
2.9. An overcrowded area and discomfort
These days especially, are the people visiting and working
in the city not complaining of discomfort due to the increasingly hot temperature?
Can we afford to say that the number of vehicles is not responsible for this
uneasiness?
Similarly, the city is becoming overcrowded due to the
number of vehicles in circulation and parked along the roads in the centre
of Port Louis. At any time during the working week, there are traffic jams
along the main routes. And above all, the pedestrians are having less and
less walking space. Certainly, it is too overcrowded over there.
2.10. Resulting effects on the workers
The environmental problems do in fact have their impacts
on the workers. They may not be apparent yet. We are living with the consequences
of this race against time, which accounts for most of the pressures of life.
To what extent could we bear such conditions? We are all making lots of efforts to have a
better living. At the end of the day, are we really better off?
This question could hardly be answered in the affirmative.
We are all suffering from the modern disease, which is stress. There is no
miraculous remedy to get rid of it, because it has
become part of our lives unwillingly. Hence, we now talk
of stress management and where there is management there is control. It means
that we need to control the level of pressures in our daily lives. Therefore,
we should see to it that we could regulate those things that are controllable.
And we can no doubt take control of the unnecessary pressures of travelling
to work and back. Such endeavour would nullify to a large extent the harmful
effects on the health of the workers. Do we not say that the good health of
the labour force is a requisite for a healthy national economy?
2.11. Risk of paralysis
Without surprising anyone, it can be said that traffic
jam could take the whole of Mauritius hostage. The Camp Chapelon roadblock
by rioters is very fresh in our memories. A few stones did cause a lot of
concern to the whole nation. We are back to the wall in such a situation,
because Port Louis is overcrowded by vehicles and is completely paralysed
owing to its bottleneck exits. Could we afford to be in such a vulnerable
position, should a similar trouble repeat itself?
3. PORT LOUIS
- Facing more pressures
3.1. An overexploited surface area and tension
Surface overexploitation has been undertaken without
consideration of the possible side effects. At this moment there is the strong
and constant feeling of overcrowding everywhere along the main streets and
the tall buildings considerably affect the air space. The question that should
be asked is to what extent Port Louis could accommodate further infrastructure
developments? Is it not high time to move away new developments to alternative
locations? With the passage of time, such practice has even been accelerated
instead of setting up a
defined policy for proper infrastructure development.
Huge buildings are being constructed without parking facilities for both residents
and visitors.
There is no proper planning for infrastructure developments.
Therefore constructions are made all over the place without consideration
for breathing space and nor for parking requirements. Hence, most of the vehicles
resort to parking along roads and other corners. As a result of the overexploitation,
there is an ever-lasting tension during weekdays in the air, which makes the
people tensed as well. This has also its psychological effect.
3.2. Over-concentration of activities
For years it has been said here and there that decentralisation
is being overdue, but no action has been taken so far. Instead, Government
activities have been more concentrated in Port Louis area.
In this juncture private business activities have been compelled to
follow the same path. Do we really need to be in Port Louis to conduct our
daily business?
We should now consider seriously the displacement of
existing ministries and other departments that are not fully dependant on
Port Louis. Examples include sectors like sports, social security, arts and
culture. The advancements in communication and information technology have
virtually eliminated distance constraints and therefore in many situations
geographical position does not matter at all. The Internet, Intranet, LAN
and WAN are vital tools that are at our disposal for quick and better access,
and even permanent contact. And
especially that we are talking a lot of an information-based
economy.
Here, I would suggest that the land area around La Vigie
is at present fully available at no opportunity cost and could accommodate
new developments. And why not the Cyber City?
4. WORLD BANK CONSULTANTS PROPOSALS: Drawbacks
4.1. The Light train
The light train would have been the best solution to
our problem. It is a very speedy and mass means of transport. A modern transport
for modern times as so many have stated, but other
reports have highlighted its non-viability. The cost
of ticket per passenger has been estimated to be higher compared to actual
equivalent bus fare for the trip between Curepipe and Port Louis. The big
question that needs to be asked here is who will pay for the bill?
It should be noted that the main reason most of the people
travel to Port Louis is to attend duty. Taking into consideration that travelling
expenditure is fully refunded by the employers according to the Law, it follows
that it is finally the government that will pay for the cost of tickets. Does
this make sense? Additionally, the cost of maintenance is expected to be very
high. Should this means of transport be extended to a larger part of the country,
and then the cost of investment could be justified.
Actually, it is not the case, as it would serve only
a short trip and a restricted number of travellers. Only we could expect that
some buses would disappear from the road, but all the other problems would
still be present. It is not certain that the people would stop travelling
by cars. Most importantly, the light train would not be able to reach the
centre of Port Louis. In contrast, buses could easily do so without the need
for feeder services and this is the only motivation that would encourage the
people to keep their cars in the garage.
The light train, based on the latest report, would require
a number of new policies, restructuring, traffic restraint and so forth for
its successful implementation. All this could cause a lot of chaos and damage
to other activities, concerned parties and road users. The biggest concern
is about the risks of unemployment and loss of business in the transport industry.
Likewise, there would be the need for specific land for
installations in respect to the light train. Port Louis is relatively a small
area, we would not expect several train stations and hence, it would mean
that the travellers would have a further distance to go before reaching their
offices. The light train system thus would not provide the flexibility, as
the buses would do.
4.2. The Bus lane
The bus lane would necessitate as well huge investment.
This option would allow only the easy circulation of buses to Port Louis and
nothing more. The present situation could as well worsen further. The traffic
congestion would be enhanced as a result of an increase in the flow of vehicles
at the same time through the bottlenecks at the entrance of Port Louis. The
pressures on the city would increase as well. It seems that there would be
even more problems to sort out. It should be noted that this option would
also cover the distance between Curepipe and Port Louis. And, the other problems
as highlighted above in section 2 would prevail. Therefore, would the required
big investment be justified? Is it the right solution?
4.3 The Kerb-Guided
Bus System
This alternative system is nothing more than the complete
substitute to the light train. Therefore, there is no need to elaborate further,
as the same drawbacks apply as in the case ofthe light train.
5. THE NEW PROPOSAL - The all-in-one Solution
The traffic is the source of all our problems as outlined
above. Therefore, the real solution
should basically be centred on the control of traffic. This is the key point
in this new solution. Now, we move to the most important part of this report,
the solution, which consists of the following steps.
5.1. Removal of traffic - removal of problems in Port
Louis
As everybody knows, the traffic is our main problem.
So, let us get rid of it and all our other problems are solved! I propose
to restrict maximum access to Port Louis at least during weekdays. With less
traffic, the City would not choke and the roads would be free, thus enabling
the workers to be right in time at office. Therefore, this would help to restore
the productivity and the efficiency level as expected. This point might seem
a little odd, but it is just one part of the picture. So, let us see the whole
picture!
5.2. Ban all full day public parking
Next, we should ban all public parking in the main area
of activity. The roads would then allow easy access in and out of the City.
Only vehicles that are holder of a valid pass for private parking would be
allowed to enter unchecked by the various Police checkpoints. A heavy fine
should penalise unauthorised parking. Here, the car owners might be very unhappy.
Well, there is a national problem and we have to help together to solve it.
But, finally they would be better off. Wait and see!
5.3. Close the Victoria Bus Station
This bus station would no more be needed under this plan,
as buses would have farther access within Port Louis. The buses would be prohibited
to park in the main area. I suggest that the trouble with the Çmarchands ambulantsÈ
would be over by that time. I would propose that most of this area should
be allocated to them with all the required facilities to earn their living.
The other part should come to the taxi operators with more space than presently.
5.4. Open routes exclusively for buses
With the closure of the Victoria Bus Station, all the
buses irrespective of routes would have to move around with no right to park
except at the Champ de Mars area or other reserved roads. Specific routes
would have to be traced to enable them to drive to the main points of the
Capital. These routes should be one way as far as possible. The buses should
not enter and leave Port Louis along the same routes in order to avoid possible
traffic problems again.
There would be no waiting buses, as they would be obliged
to go around the traced routes as from the designated bus parks outside the
central area. Alternatively, parking provisions could be made as well. It
would be addressed later on.
5.5. Incentives for executive coaches and longer buses
In the light of the new era in Port Louis many people,
and among whom there would be top executives, would be motivated to travel
by bus to attend work. It would be more fun and leisure than driving their
own cars given the daily stress of the drivers, like to face traffic jam,
finding a proper parking slot and the probability of accidents, and especially
that cars would be prohibited of access in Port Louis centre. Government should
provide incentives to companies and other organisations to operate executive
coaches.
In addition, bus companies should be encouraged to acquire
longer buses for mass
transportation, let say 70 seats or more. Not only the
number of the passengers per trip would increase, but also the number of buses
would decrease on our main roads.
Here, special attention should be given to the type of
buses to be permitted to enter Port Louis area. It should be mandatory that
the new buses should be modern, comfortable and environment-friendly. However,
a long transition period would have to be observed before the existing buses
could be fully replaced. Pending the total replacement it should be a must
that all existing buses should be pollution-free as required by the Law. Hence,
no black smoke, no oil leakages and no abnormal mechanical noise should be
allowed. Strict application of the law should be made in a view to reduce
all vehicle-based pollutions. Infringements of the law should be severely
penalized.
5.6. Bus stops at central points
Thus, we could afford to have bus stops at key points
in Port Louis. There could be, for example, a bus stop at Emmanuel Anquetil
Building, one at the Government House, another at Cernée House, etc. The location
of bus stops would depend largely on the bus routes to be traced and the concentration
of passengers. Of course, this design would require technical support of the
specialists in this domain.
5.7. Transit parking
Provisions would have to be made for visitors to Port
Louis and special paid parking should be provided for let say a maximum of
2 to 3 hours. For this purpose, the roads with low traffic away from the main
centre should be used and should be strictly controlled to avoid illegal practices.
Other places like the Cathedral Square could also be reserved for such purpose.
Given the availability of space under the new proposal,
temporary parking could also be allowed near key business units like the SBM,
the MCB, Registrar General's Office, etc. Such facility should be limited
to customers and other visitors only. The respective organisations should
be requested to make reservations and to pay a monthly fee in addition to
parking fees paid by the users.
Similarly, attention should be paid to trucks driving
into Port Louis especially for loading and unloading mainly in the wholesale
area. Transit parking should be provided for such vehicles along roads in
that region. Reservations would have to be made by the wholesalers and other
importers against a monthly fee. Equally, the truck owners should pay a parking
fee. The duration restrictions as mentioned above should also apply. Same
arrangements should be made for the central market.
5.8. INTRODUCTION OF CAR STATIONS - The only solution
This is a word that probably I am the first to use in
Mauritius. The Car Station is simply a huge and highly secured parking for
the vehicles driving to Port Louis. I firmly believe that it is the most direct,
practical and cost-effective solution to our traffic problems after taking
into consideration all the factors discussed so far.
The eradication of traffic jam and related problems within
Port Louis could only be done by controlling the flow of vehicles. If we cannot
break the neck of the bottle, then we have to regulate the flow in order that
we can keep things moving. Hence, the idea of a Car Station comes right in
time to solve our big problems, because the City has no more room for further
cost-effective and environment-friendly road developments. Obviously, the
Car Station has to be away from the bottleneck.
Large plots of land have been identified at Soreze on
both sides of the highway just before
the "morcellement" and also at Pailles opposite
the underpass. They are partly under sugar cane cultivation at present and
apparently belong to private owners. However, the growth of the crops is in
bad shape and it is understood that the land is either not fertile or very
arid. As such the opportunity cost is marginal. I propose that the land should
compulsorily be acquired (under the Compulsory Acquisition Act) on the ground
of national interest, but the owners
should be fairly compensated to the extent that the Law
allows it.
In short, the Car Stations at Soreze and Pailles would
provide parking facilities for all vehicles driving to Port Louis through
the south and west entrances respectively. There are various options as regards
to the structure of the Car Stations. It could range from the simple surface
parking to a modern multi-storey parking. It would largely depend on the number
of vehicles. Certainly, a parking fee would be payable. No parking other than
private and transit parking would be allowed in Port Louis.
Along with the operation of these two Car Stations, similar
structures could be needed at the
north and east entrances. However, we should proceed
by phases, starting with that of Soreze
and Pailles in the first instance. Pending the introduction
of the other two car stations if
needed, the vehicles from north and east entrances could
be allowed to be parked at Champ
de Mars equally against payment of a parking fee. Same
security arrangements would apply.
The in-and-out access to the Car Stations would be another
very technical aspect to be given
due attention. To avoid any traffic problems there would
be several alternatives to be
considered among a fly-over, underpass and a link road
to the underpass at Pailles. Hence, the
best access would have to be found, which would be the
job of the experts. Furthermore, it
would be expected that there would be increased pressure
over the Phoenix Roundabout
especially during the afternoon, as the flow of traffic
would be very fast as from the Car
Station. This would lead to an expected traffic jam,
because presently there are already some
problems at this level. Some road adjustments would need
to be made to ease the rising flow
of traffic. I would propose a direct road bypassing the
roundabout for vehicles moving
towards the roundabout at Highlands. This measure would
prevent these vehicles from
converging at the roundabout at Phoenix and the pressure
would hence decrease substantially.
Provisions would also have to be made for vehicles moving
towards the Industrial zone of
Phoenix, Valentina and around. There is enough room for
such adjustments and a plan could
be worked out thereafter.
This proposal draws no comparison with all other options,
that is, fly-overs, circular road, bus lane and light train as far as financing
is concerned. The Car Stations would generate its own income in terms of parking
fees and royalties paid on the resulting commercial activities in its vicinity.
In the long term, it should be able to recover the initial investment made
and
afterwards to earn profits. As such, there would be no
significant financial burden on both the
government and the people.
The biggest complaint, that road users would raise, would
be about their established
convenience - the ease of being near to parking and to
office. However, the consequences are
mainly traffic jam, parking problem, resulting stress,
time wastage and driving pressures. The
Car Stations would remove all these problems and above
all would provide further
advantages like easy access to parking, security services,
car care centres, filling stations,
one-stop shops, hypermarkets and other common services
to be developed alongside. There
could be nothing better than all this-a new and better
way of life for all of them. The only
effort that they would have to make would be to park
their vehicles at the Car Station and get
on the link travel service to their workplaces. The expense
and time required for this short
trip are almost the same when compared to driving during
the hectic hours over the same
distance. And additionally, other than the benefits,
I believe that as citizens of this country we all have a duty to do this little
extra effort to solve our national problems. As well, our Capital City really
needs this effort from us to restore its good health. We should not wait until
it is too late to take action.
The last question that requires attention here is undoubtedly
about link services between the
Car Stations and the central points of Port Louis. The
success of the Car Station would
depend fully on the efficiency of the feeder services,
which are dealt with below.
5.9. Feeder services
In the first instance, I would propose 30 buses of 25
seats to provide the link service. They
should be able to reach the centre within 5 minutes and
not more. On one hand there would
be less traffic on the roads and on the other hand they
would drive along bus routes. They
would thus access all focal points of the Port Louis
area. Such services would be available
mostly during the peaks hours and outside this time frame,
the normal bus service on this
route would operate by a detour in and out of the Car
Stations. We should expect that the
buses would deliver a rapid service at all times. Thus,
the feeder services should take the
minimum time to travel from the Car Station to the nearest
point of the offices. I could state
that overall it should be less than the time needed by
car actually taking into consideration
delays caused by traffic jams, the time for parking and
the time to walk to office points. We
should expect that the buses should be fully pollution-free.
Furthermore, an alternative to
buses could be introduced and it is discussed below.
Before we would move to that alternative, I would wish
to address the issue of affected
parties, when buses would have direct access to the centre
of Port Louis. These parties would
be mainly taxi operators and bus operators providing
short services within or through the
heart of the City. Should the financial loss be considerable,
I would propose that these parties should be offered priority over acquisition
of shares in the newly formed companies to
operate feeder services. An appropriate agreement would
have to be reached accordingly.
5.10. Tramway as an alternative feeder service
The other option in this case could be the tramway. According
to previous feasibility report,
it would have cost around Rs. 115 millions in terms of
investment to operate over the
distance between the north and the south bus stations.
This is a clear indication that the
tramway would cost relatively much less. I would suggest
that the most appropriate route in
this juncture should start from the Car Station at Soreze,
would go through the central part of
Port Louis, to the north bus station and back. Otherwise,
the tramway system should also be
capable to link all 3 or 4 car stations when they would
be fully operational. The tramway
system could use part of our present road infrastructure.
There is enough room for such
development.
In the event that the tramway option would be acceptable,
we could consider the prohibition
of buses as well into the City area. In such a case,
separate provisions should be made for bus
parking along the Car Stations. I should acknowledge
that this option could cause some
inconvenience to bus travellers and therefore further
study would be required for a reasonable
evaluation.
5.11. New employment
The advent of the Car Stations, and as a consequence
the feeder services, would create new
employment opportunities especially at lower grade levels.
Other than the management of the
Car Stations, other business units would be developed
as already mentioned, car care centres
and hypermarkets for example. Hence, we could expect
creation of employment as compared
to the other proposals, where there would be risk of
unemployment.
5.12. Port Louis as a green and clean City
A golden opportunity would be presented to us to make
Port Louis a very clean City. Proper
and regular cleaning would be easy to undertake given
that all the area would be very
accessible at any time of the day.
Similarly, we could make the Capital as far as possible
green subject to availability of space.
This would be a very sensible and laudable project. As
the streets would be partially free, the
possibilities of tree transplantation could be considered.
Various corners could be given a
new and green look, as it is the case in many major cities
like in Singapore, where the
environment has been duly taken care of. I believe firmly
that this action would be even
indispensable in the light of the atmospheric conditions
prevailing in Port Louis presently. It
would be our only chance to lessen the greenhouse effect.
And we would therefore prevent
the situation from further degradation.
In addition, it would be time to look after the system
of drains in Port Louis. A proper rainfall drainage system is actually badly
required. When it rains, most of the ditches overflow and as a result there
is flooding along many roads causing inconvenience to both pedestrians and
vehicles.
Well, the opportunity would be there to seize and make
the improvements as never before.
5.13. Any uncovered difficulties
Any uncovered difficulty here should be treated with
objectivity and not as an obstacle. The
scope of this proposal is merely to put forward a solution
in its broad sense. The room for
improvement is unlimited and the capacity to improvise
is very high. Let us give this
proposal its due merits. Now we move to the benefits
of the Car Stations so that we could be
convinced once for all that it would be the only real
solution.
5.14. Benefits of the Car Station
1. It would maintain status quo as regards employment
in the transport sector.
2. It would relieve us of the problems faced daily, for
example:
2.1. Traffic jams
2.2. Parking scarcities
2.3. Drivers' stress
2.4. Lost in time and energy for road users
2.5. Low productivity & efficiency
2.6. Difficult access and circulation within Port Louis
at any time of the day
2.7. Pressures & stress on employees travelling by
bus
2.8. Lateness at work
2.9. Other impacts on the health of the employees
3. Noise and air pollution would be kept under control.
4. Large savings in foreign currency reserves would be
made.
5. New employment would be created as a result of feeder
services, car care centres, parking
services, parking security services, etc.
6. There would be no long-term financial burden on the
government and the people.
7. Very low initial investment is required.
8. The Capital City would be saved from the current unsolved
problems of major
international Capitals. Hence, we should have a clean
and green Port Louis.
9. New services for car owners mainly- Car care centres,
Hypermarkets, one-stop shops,
etc.
10. A new atmosphere in Port Louis - Less crowded, more
space, less tension, more mobility,
and so on.
11. A project entirely in the national interest and based
on the Mauritian context.
12. It would be above all a self-financing project.
13. No impact on ongoing and future infrastructure developments
as far as land use is
concerned.
14. There would be easy bus access to the heart of Port
Louis.
15. The problem with "marchand ambulants" would
be solved indefinitely.
16. No new policies, restructuring and other restraints
would be needed.
6. SUPPLEMENTARY MEASURES
In addition, we could consider some additional measures,
should the need arise following the
introduction of the Car Stations. They are as follows:
6.1. Flexi-time
Several times this matter has been raised at different
levels, but concrete actions are still
awaited. Flexi-time is also a difficult concept to implement
because it requires various
conditions to be satisfied in order to be successful.
Yet, it does not mean that it is impossible to introduce. Where there is a
will, there is a way. This concept demands in fact adjustments in the present
working system. However, owing to existing constraints and specificity some
jobs or sectors would be in a difficult position to adapt successfully to
the attached conditions of flexi-time system, but the room for implementation
does remain elsewhere.
Hence, this is to show how the possibilities for flexi-time
do exist and it depends on the
policy-makers to lead the way. The benefits are numerous,
ranging from the improvement in
productivity and efficiency, job satisfaction and stress
management to resolving the transport
problems and even traffic problems.
6.2. Decentralisation of Government Services
This point has already been mentioned above and it is
becoming a must. The miracles of
information technology have made distance and location
meaningless. It is time that the
government could envisage some actions in this direction.
Some people might be asking
about the availability of office space outside Port Louis.
As an example, it is now over five
years, that the Social Security House at Rose Hill has
got free large office space.
By the way, it must be pointed out that Reduit should
have been considered as a strategic
zone. Yet, it is a pity to find out that developments
have been made just in the same manner
as squatters do. There has been no optimum use of land
in that region. Buildings have been
erected here and there with a tunnel vision, and future
developments have been sacrificed.
Reduit is such a place that could be easily and quickly
accessed from any point of the
country. This focal region should have been the best
site for decentralisation of government
activities. It is out of question to come and say that
prime land presently under sugar cane
cultivation should be used for future developments. We
should never forget that our prime
land is the foundation of our economic success and represents
the most valuable asset along
with our human resource. We cannot afford to misuse this
limited natural and profitable
economic factor. Sugar production could be unprofitable
one day, but there would be other
viable alternatives, which are now already present. This
means that we cannot use our fertile
land for other purpose than crop cultivation. Unless
that some day an oil well is found on this
land!
In addition, tall structures could have accommodated
common government services under the
same roof. It is high time to consider this issue, when
it is question of construction of new
public buildings outside Port Louis. It is shocking to
find out that public buildings have been
erected in Reduit and Phoenix, for instance, with a sub-optimality
view of the owner
organisations. There is thus very poor planning and management
in this field.
No doubt, decentralisation needs to be given due attention
in an attempt to help settle the
above national problems. Such measures would also increase
productivity and at the same
time save cost in terms of travelling refund made to
employees. This item of expenditure
represents a big share in the Government budget. Finally,
we should consider seriously the
possibility of new developments in the area around La
Vigie instead of wasting prime land.
6.3. Time of receiving public/visitors in the Public
Sector
The public visits could be set at a time which does not
coincide with the arrival of the
employees. Let us put it at 10.00 hours. This measure
would decrease the demand on the
transport service at the peak time and also the number
of vehicles would decrease on the
roads to some extent.
6.4. Working hours in the Private Sector
Moreover, most of the private sector firms do start working
earlier than in the public service.
It is commonly at 8.30 a.m. If the whole private sector
could align with the same early
practice and may be if it could be even earlier, say
8.15 am, the situation would certainly
improve on the roads and at the bus stations too. An
appeal could be made for assistance to
the private sector in the national interest.
6.5. Commercial units to be opened as from 10.a.m.
In the same line of thought, all commercial units excluding
vital services should be opened as
from 10.00 am too. The resulting effect would be the
same as discussed above. And most
importantly, the number of heavy vehicles would decrease
on the roads at peak hours and
would be a further help in eradicating traffic congestion.
7. CONCLUSION
Now it is obvious that traffic jams are not stand-alone
problems, but rather they do trigger
other problems too, affecting the people and the environment
at the same time. For this
reason we should look over the situation with a global
view. And we should consider a global
solution, which should meet both present and future demands.
The solution proposed here is a revolutionary one as
it has the ability to tackle all these
aspects simultaneously. And most importantly it is more
practical, comparatively cheap and
without mentioning that it is self-financing. It has
a lot of advantages that the other suggested
solutions could hardly provide. The most anticipated
obstacle is to make the road users adapt
to a new habit. It is just a question of days, and finally
they would realise that the derived
benefits would outweigh their supposed inconvenience.
A resistance is always a common feature when change is about to come. This
is human nature and this is a natural reaction. A change management strategy
should be adopted to prepare the people for the coming change.
I wish to mention that I have conceived this solution
years back as part of a vision of a better country for my fellow compatriots.
I believe in possibilities and we have the means to
achieve a great deal of improvements in this country.
I am making the proposal to the government as the crucial
decision is now under consideration. I would be very grateful to assist in
its design and implementation, of course in the event that this solution would
be accepted. And especially, I expect that there would be many possibilities
to be explored and a lot of improvisation to be made in order to achieve
the optimum solution. As any other projects, there would
always be both foreseeable and
unforeseeable constraints to deal with. I remain at the
total disposal of this project to provide my best assistance.
Finally, I am very proud as a Mauritian to have worked
out such a big proposal and this is a
100 percent Mauritius-made solution. I seize this opportunity
to express my deep gratitude to
a few good and reliable friends for their contribution
in one way or another in the preparation
of this document.
Now, I hope that the solution proposed here would be
welcomed by one and all in the
national interest and for the benefit of the whole nation.
Shiwraj PITTEA
Market Road
Rose Belle
E-mail:
Shivajee_2000@yahoo.co.uk
3
May 2001